New Book Targets Helicopter Parenting
There’s a new, brutally frank book called A Nation of Wimps: The High Cost of Invasive Parenting, by Hara Estroff Marano (www.nationofwimps.com/). It really has me thinking. Am I raising my kids to depend on me for everything? Sure, I’ve read and agreed with most of Wendy Mogel’s The Blessing of a Skinned Knee (www.wendymogel.com/books.html), but have I followed its principles to allow my children to fall on their butts now so they learn how to get back up on their own power?
I battle with myself almost daily about being appropriately protective and educational. Just the other night, my wife and I discussed the fact that our kindergartner is not reading yet. The teacher said the other kids in the class were reading and she didn’t want our kid to lag. She wasn’t mean about it but she did alarm us. Should we work with our son every night, drill him, get him a tutor, as some parents seem to be doing even at this early stage of education? Up till this point, it hadn’t been a concern because our oldest didn’t learn to read until he was well into first grade — well behind his classmates. His teacher told us not to push, to let our child struggle and come to reading on his own steam. Now he consumes books out of the joy of reading. Certainly, our kids are different, but we are going to refrain from making a federal case out of it and let him fail a little. We have faith that he’ll learn to read and realize that he doesn’t need us to move his eyes across the page.
I’m not sure if this is a perfect example of how to avoid invasive parenting, but it is one touchpoint of concern in an age in which many moms and dads believe good parenting means hand-holding a child through school, friendships, athletics, and more. A Nation of Wimps addresses the dangers too much coddling can lead to, including depression and aimlessness in kids as they grow older. The author also offers approaches to helping our children take smart risks and make decisions for themselves. As shattering as the book can be to our own sense of being good, involved parents, it is worth the pain now to learn how to raise strong, independent human beings.